San Diego City Wire

Senate Minority Leader Brian W. Jones and Senator Shannon Grove have urged Governor Newsom to veto Senate Bill 403, authored by Senator Wahab. The bill has been criticized for potentially targeting and racially profiling South Asian Californians.

Leader Jones expressed concerns about the bill's implications, stating, "We’ve received countless calls from constituents and Californians across the state in opposition to the measure. It’s my job to represent their concerns in Sacramento." He further questioned the necessity of referencing a caste system in law, noting that "caste and ancestry discrimination are already illegal."

The bill has sparked division within the South Asian community and among legislators. Many Hindu organizations have voiced strong opposition. Critics argue that there is no substantial evidence of widespread caste discrimination in California, pointing out that a frequently cited survey by Equality Labs lacks scientific credibility. Furthermore, a legal case concerning caste discrimination was dismissed by the Santa Clara Superior County Court.

Senator Grove also raised concerns about the potential consequences of SB 403, saying, "SB 403 will encourage the discrimination and profiling of our South East Asian community, especially those who embrace the Hindu religion." She highlighted issues with the bill's broad definition of “perceived position” in social stratification systems, which could lead to baseless discrimination charges against businesses.

The senators' letter to Governor Newsom included excerpts expressing worries about adding "caste" to California law definitions. They argued this move could deny constitutional rights to equal protection and due process for South Asians and Hindus specifically.

They warned that assuming inherent bigotry among South Asians might discourage employers from hiring them, affecting business innovation in California. The letter emphasized concerns over vague definitions in SB 403 that could lead to various interpretations and accusations of discrimination.

The senators concluded their appeal by requesting a veto on SB 403 due to its potentially disastrous consequences for California.